he has the better deal imho. being rich but not utterly famous. I bet he is free to go to Mcdonalds unbothered, if he wanted to. Being famous is a golden prison.

the modern carpenters

@@robertschiller5422 Absolutely not everyone knows who he is cause u never really see them apart. They come as a package deal.

FINNEAS gets a lot more credit for Billie Eilish's success than most producers/songwriters/piano players/backup singers. Maybe that's not a fair deal, but it's the status quo for the entire industry.

​@@tadeuszmusicexplained so well!! I totally agree!

Honestly

Love the orchestra

That was a beautiful revel ❤

Let us hear the conclusion of the whole matter: Fear God, and keep his commandments: for this is the whole duty of man. Ecclesiastes 12:13

@@ayoolukoga9829got spoiled by the comment lmao

@@larrymant1484you mean that is your opinion?

no it's not one of the best wtf

@@larrymant1484oh but billie will always be famous .. idk if u even know what moaning is but this def wasn't moaning ☠️ ya ass provably got an ear infection

@@larrymant1484& plus this song is meant to be gentle , and quiet idk what tf ur on about

@@larrymant1484well no .. she wasnt moaning ☠️ this song is meant to be sung in a quiet and gentle way like what tf u want her to do start screaming the lyrics? It does not fit the song

I'm actively trying to whisper like that and I can't. 😢

indeed....

Right…Especially over an entire orchestra…no whispering here.

Exactly. Soft singing is quite difficult.

And not permanently damage your voice at that

* 9 Grammys and "2 Oscars" (not belittling this recognition)

😂🤦🏽‍♂️​@@angelestorres6334

She is an American

No shes just another reason why you cant take the oscars serious anymore. whiny without any skill.

And she is trying to help children in need in the middle east ❤🍉

this.

The way she sings her songs will always remind me of the day when I was young I heard ocean eyes and knew I was gonna love her forever

@CharlieRuyung fake

I find her tone and delivery to be rather weak.

@@reconeix is it bc she kinda whispers

She probably sung it 1000 times. but yes this song is really emotional!

@panameraboomin7925 I have no idea!! It's impressive. I can't imagine how hard it must have been writing and recording it initially.

I cry every time

I'm literally crying while typing this this song always makes me so emotional

the sound is the lyrics arent shit thats why

Let us hear the conclusion of the whole matter: Fear God, and keep his commandments: for this is the whole duty of man. Ecclesiastes 12:13

I think it’s such a testament to the beauty of their relationship and how much they both adore and admire each other. Every time I see them perform, it’s like magic! 🪄 ✨

finneas

@@raeganivory1 Phinehas' wife, was with child, near to be delivered: and when she heard the tidings that the ark of God was taken, and that her father in law and her husband were dead, she bowed herself and travailed; for her pains came upon her. 1 Samuel 4:19

He’s the brother everyone wishes they had.

@@reconeix what you mean? Still requires her to hit specific notes, control vocal and most importantly, connect with her audience.

@@reconeixWhat she’s doing is very hard and not many vocalists can pull it off to this level.

@@reconeixyou’re just plain wrong lol

@@reconeix Lol, what a pathetic human being. Someeone talks about how much they like a performance, and you discredit their feelings by saying their feelings are invalid because 'It's not great enough to get in history books'. Like, who cares about history anyways? It matters that this song has an important meaning to us. Go touch some grass.

​@@reconeixThere's a reason why even a lot more experienced singers than Billie don't sing like this or attempt to. It's very difficult, and for some it's impossible

Sounds like someone is dead😂

@@AnnaF33and also their dog died 😂

That breaks anyone

@@AnnaF33you jealous broke

@@samsunganycall1 ya laughing?

Me too❤😢

Something I forgot something I can be something wait for something I’m made for, absolutely beautiful!

Yes!!!! I think I forgot how to be happy something I’m not but something i can be, something i wait for something I’m made for. Literally made me sob the first time i heard it

I paused for a while , reflecting on my inner self .... That was me

Along with "Don't tell my boyfriend. Its not what he's made for." It was just kind of recognizing that all people come with limitations and Ken was not built for the complex emotions that Barbie was feeling. He is not "less" or anything - he is just who he is

Word for word it hits! I’m too overwhelmed to cry but I know it’s coming

absolutely!!!

Thats where we need the men! In the shadows and deferential! I agree

That's what good big brothers do 💚

@@George2647gdude really wtf

I believe Billie’s shy and doesn’t have enough self esteem so that’s why Finneas is there to support her, besides being very talented himself. It’s a wonderful sibling relationship.

They line themselves with Jew Killers!!!!

​@Manman-uj2hmf off with ur trashy video

​@Manman-uj2hm thanks for sharing i put a dislike ❤

❤❤❤

🥱😴

❤❤❤

Because you’ve still got a big beautiful heart underneath all the trauma. 🩷

art sometimes does that to you. always intense when it happens. I wish you the best on your path forward

Combat teaches you to be strong. Music like this cuts through the thickest of hides.

It's beautiful, but it's not "the most"

Ryan gosling was so much better

@@Benb1039😭😭😭 in your dreams

Agree

Why

how about the ear at left?

@@mzdr2705🤣🤣

Ew.

@@annaanthony9707 ew what⁉️⁉️

Nothing like it

👍

I hope their period of this immense creativity lasts very long and we get to experience a lot of more beautiful songs of them both.🤩🎉🙂👍🏼

What was I made for. Song asks the question mankind has been puzzled with since Adam & Eve.

Hearing their voices harmonize knowing they’re siblings is just that much more powerful. The simplicity is everything.

@@bri276this song is so amazing because is doesn’t try hard is just about doubt it sounds simple but is such a hard theme

This...your expression...is so beautiful...🤗 Thank you...🖤

Currently bawling as well. This song hits me every time, especially when she sings it live

Yes music is still alive folks!!I could conform that and i am 52🙂✌✌

I agree! Just beautiful! She is so talented!

Every moment of this video is so beautiful…Billie’s voice, Finneas accompaniment, the orchestra, the lyrics and how supportive Finneas at the end to give applause for Billie. Truly heartwarming

Bro you are everywhere 😭😭

I'm sorry I see you everywhere..

Why are you everywhere

"Intense but fragile," really nicely put.

Chef’s briss *

She is just whispering. It’s not rocket science

@@wadewilson1312stfu you clearly don’t know anything about music

@@wadewilson1312weird…”just whispering” doesn’t include hitting musical notes, yet she does indeed hit many notes. Sounds like a cognitive distortion, trying to simplify and categorize her singing as just whispering. If you miss that much in life…let me tell you, there are more colors than just black and white. If you can’t hear, see, understand, complexity, nuance, it doesn’t mean it doesn’t exist. You just don’t have the wiring to “get” it. Your reality is one of many, and it’s not absolute!

fr, the best someday I’ve ever heard

He's amazing on his own too. Check out his KZbin videos. Very talented duo.

I actually wasn't even aware that her brother was playing piano for her. My older brother is absolutely irreplaceable. I've loved this song so much already but I'm thankful to be enlightened on the sibling connection so it's very meaningful on a 2nd level now as well.

@@killatay2818his brother produces her records and writes some of her songs too

@@mateobenavidez1985 Nice!

666 likes, nice

Finally someone said this! Simple expressions in whatever art form is extremely hard. Everything is exposed and thus vulnerable. I know this first-hand as a creative person myself. This performance was brilliant because they knew exactly what to keep and what to discard which is a talent in of itself.

And it's such a relatable song. "Where did it end, all the enjoyment/I'm sad again, don't tell my boyfriend"is quite the relatable lyric. As someone who went through complete burnout I unfortunately know that feeling, not knowing what you even enjoyed in life and not wanting to hurt people by showing them your sadness and being unsure is something I wish more people talked about in their art.

It is indeed a perfect example of less is more, sometimes that is a winning formula.

Well, as a singer, I think she was really scared or stressed, and that impacted her breath support when she started the performance, but she became confident after looking at her brother. And yes, people think hitting high notes is difficult (yes, some are indeed), but singing in that style requires a lot of breath control to remain on pitch all the time and avoid nasality or straining. She did a great job without in-ear monitors on top of that.

@@archmichaels​​⁠​⁠Did she really not have in-ears? Her brother did, I doubt she didn’t have them tbh.

@@archmichaelsActually yes she is wearing them, you can see it on her right ear at the right angle

Well of course because she rehearse duhh

Yeah it's crazy keeping that perfect tone and enunciation that quiet, especially swapping from head to chest voice and back all song.

In my eyes he is 🥰 Love the support and the creations his makes!

Exactly The comment I was looking for ❤❤❤😊😊😊😊

I love them sm 😭

Such an amazing and beautiful comment! I agree 100%!

My bet is he doesn't need or want the recognition that Billie gets, while performing "her" songs. Most songwriters just want the recognition for being songwriters, which is mostly behind the scenes. Obviously, when he sings his own songs, I'm sure he wants his own recognition.

That speaks to their humility. Which makes me admire them so much more.

@@amellowman i don't think finneas or billie had anything to do with this upload..

They said "y'all" as in the channel that uploaded it lol ​@@philip4436

Exactly was I was looking for

Because it was expected, It would have been very surprising if that had not been the case. We'll just have to imagine the ovation 😷

He’s the best brother

They are unstoppable together, beautiful bond, its so heartwarming seeing them loving each other this much

is it just me or is she crying when she sings the line? its so beautiful

Check out her singing it at "Live from Lollapalooza Chicago 2023" , thank me later after dry your eyes.

I wonder why she sings in a different pitch compared to original song

​@@AM5artor Different key?🤷‍♀️

@@AM5artorbecause it’s a very strenuous song to constantly sing. she mostly changes the keys when she’s at festivales/performing more than one song. in this performance it’s the same as the official song, unless my ears deceive me.

​@@bees.1600You make your own family (in a found family sort of way), surround yourself with people who do love you and like you. I'm struggling with this myself so I can only offer so much.

I did, lost my sister in ‘95. Bonds of siblings are so real, truly beyond words. Beautiful to see it in others 🤍

@@sayusayme7729may she rest in peace ❤

Woah! Great point! I have 2 children myself & I'm always proud of them. But you're so right to imagine what it might be like if your offspring do this Oscar performance together. 🤯

Incest

Это ее брат,?

7 grammy and 2 oscars at 22 bro she is killing it

@@goodgreif5838absolutely. She and her brother deserve it. Bless you

@@goodgreif5838 9 grammys actually

This song is meaningful to men also.

When you are 12 year old maybe

Let us hear the conclusion of the whole matter: Fear God, and keep his commandments: for this is the whole duty of man. Ecclesiastes 12:13

​@Kittycute357 He's lying🤦‍♂️ don't go over, it's better to report spam 🤡

@Kittycute357 lmao im so fucking stupid for falling for it it sent me to a vid on asmr soap carving i cant 💀

​​@@amaliscoolreallmao ( love your pfp)

Хочу е😊😅😅😊😅

​@@amaliscoolreal kzbin.info/www/bejne/gXrWnZ5teKuloposi=Opra2cw25-eYZ5va

She's asking a basic human question 😅

Let us hear the conclusion of the whole matter: Fear God, and keep his commandments: for this is the whole duty of man. Ecclesiastes 12:13

On that note, the voice quality is superb.

oh so your sayin she sucks

No friend. It isn't acting. It's the anointing from God the Creator, blessing his creation with a gift that will heal the masses. It's a gift. Cannot be learned or purchased. It's called the anointing, and it always comes with a great price; suffering and heartbreak. ❤

​@Kittycute357He's lying🤦‍♂️ don't go over, it's better to report spam 🤡

Congratulations love

@AlacoqueHartsoe spam 🤮🤡

You better swing the other way then!

Her voice 🎤🎼

Nothing beats familial vocal harmony.

How about the left ear?

​@@Vapedealerband She and her brother composed all of her songs so far

@@Vapedealerband Lying comes easy to you, doesn't it?

I remember being floored to learn she wrote all the boy band songs in Turning Red

​​@@VapedealerbandShe and Phineas are the composers. Dont say shit.

​@@VapedealerbandShe writes her songs with her brother 💀

AGREED, it was a great reaction after the performance. They should have left it in the video.

Not better, it's just here she chose to open up more as it is big venue. Occasion needed to expand the intimate holdback of the original recording and they have done it perfectly. They turned the notch up just enough. He is really musical genius and she is a great vocalist, this was beautiful. Intimacy on a grand subdued scale.

​@@jonaswunderkind4580 true, but I guess the "whisper singing" on the studio version was too much for me so I prefer this one lol

The thing that's really surprising is that her live performance is the exact same as the studio performance. Not many can do this.

She, of all people, knows what an incredible musician Finneas is. Watch his own music video, with Billie and the other siblings standing with him at the end! kzbin.info/www/bejne/mGOug5ZrntGMiMUsi=yNZRNKEG5bHiDniR

Same 👍

Same

The most organic the better

Hi! I am Billie's agent and she personally asked me to thank you!

🏆😻

No

Let us hear the conclusion of the whole matter: Fear God, and keep his commandments: for this is the whole duty of man. Ecclesiastes 12:13

​@@ayoolukoga9829 girl shut ur ass up I'm listening to billie ain't have time to hear ur shit hahaha 😂

I also😍♥️

Jesus loves you ❤️ so so much. It is his desire to be with you. He longs for you. All you have to do is repent and give up all sin to follow him. His word says "Come to me, all you who are weary and burdened, and I will give you rest." If you are going through anything, he is right there waiting for you, constantly waiting for you to come to him. God gave up everything he loved through his son Jesus just for the chance that you might love him back. He is waiting with open arms. And time is short. These are the last days. I say all this because I care and don't want any of you to perish and neither does he. Please turn to him and repent now while there is still time. He loves you. The God of all creation actually loves you. There are things that don't always make sense in this life, things that cause us to blame God, and believe me I've been there too over some extremely heart-wrenching situations but he is a God who will never leave us nor forsake us so long as we stay with him. He is the complete expression of love. Just give him a chance. His heart longs for you. He chose you when he planned creation. You are not a mistake. His thoughts towards you outnumber the grains of sand. He died for you. The God of all creation let himself be nailed to a cross and suffer for you so you don't have to. Please make the right decision to repent and turn to Jesus to receive salvation now while there is still time, because it is almost the end. All you have to do is believe in your heart and confess with your mouth and say "God in heaven, I come to you in the name of Jesus, I confess that I am a sinner in need of your Grace. I believe with my heart and confess with my mouth that Jesus died on the cross for my sins and rose from the dead. Please forgive me God for all my sins and please come into my heart and my life Jesus. I confess that Jesus is Lord and I make you Jesus, Lord and saviour of my life in Jesus name. Amen." Also be on the lookout for the mark of the beast soon to come. This will be something that ALL will be required to take either on/in their right arm or forehead and will be necessary to buy and sell things and essentially live. No matter what, do not take this mark because those who take it may be beyond saving.

Hey Billie so glad that you & Finneas have shown support over ceasefire! Love you.

its not that deep

Not necessary to use filth words yukkkkk

Yeah, they definitely didn't think as far

@@annisabaksh4533 L + ratio

@@koddokk cool comment :)

Lol I don't even think it would crack the top 50.... you do know there used to be a time where good movies were made every year and they had great songs in them that were nominated...sung by generational talents....Celine Dion, Whitney Houston, Adele, Judy Garland, Phil Collins.... It wasn't even the best performance of the night for Christ sake lol... Ryan Goslings performance blows this out of the water.

Perfectly said.

It’s about women’s human experience in today’s society.

Makes my four yr old cry everytime it’s really strange

It is incredibly relatable to so many women. This is a song I could never grow tired of 🤍

My parents raised my brothers and I right but the oldest one turned out to be a total jerk. Such is life. But none of us went to prison or did drugs.

Nope, she sucks.

Agreed! She also has a powerhouse voice that she displays in some of her other songs. She has such incredible range.

For sure! We will see her perform for many years to come!

Those who say she sounds like she's "just whispering" are tone deaf, deaf-deaf, or are simply mistaking her for Dido. HA 😁

At 66, I could have written those exact words. Thank you for sharing your introspection. ❤️

Can I ask you something? I need help. After 10 years of depression and disconnecting from general living. Losing all my dependance early on. Having to face reality with nothing but deja vu and disappointment. Funerals and self harm. Being tortured by the fact I'm not strong enough to take an easy way out. Too weak to be better. And now your too afraid of life altogether How do you learn to live again. I'm only 29

Disney has a documentary musical about Billie. There are songs she sang with a few orchestras that are not on KZbin (especially Therefor I Am was so impressive that I think it was at the 50th minute with the orchestra).

When they offer you an Oscars-level-worthy orchestra, and the stage that goes with it, that's when you know you've transcended as a global artist

I was sobbing when this came on during the movie. Did not expect that. Happy she won

So true. My voice would be cracking up mid-song, if I were her. Due to the lump in my throat, triggered by thinking about the lyrics

It looked like she was so close like 2 separate times and it GUTTED me.

​@@Kaalyn_HOW kzbin.info/www/bejne/gXrWnZ5teKuloposi=Opra2cw25-eYZ5va